The Winklevoss-owned cryptocurrency exchange, Gemini, has become the latest platform to announce its exit from the Canadian market. Citing mounting regulatory challenges, Gemini plans to close all customer accounts in Canada by December 31, 2024. This decision follows a string of similar exits by major exchanges, including Binance and OKX, which have also been unable to navigate Canada’s increasingly stringent compliance environment.
Regulatory Burden Forces Gemini To Exit Canada
The regulatory environment for cryptocurrency exchanges in Canada has been evolving rapidly. The Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) are at the center of these changes, which introduced new regulations to increase investor protection. A key aspect of these rules is the requirement for crypto trading platforms to sign pre-registration undertakings (PRUs) to continue operating. This pre-registration framework restricts the use of stablecoins and tightens oversight on how exchanges manage assets and liquidity.
In a statement to its Canadian users, Gemini set a December 31 deadline for closing all accounts, giving customers 90 days to withdraw their assets. The exchange did not cite specific reasons for its exit. However, the growing complexity of meeting regulatory standards is widely believed to be the driving factor. This mirrors the decisions made by other crypto giants like Binance, which left the Canadian market in May 2023. They declared the new requirements untenable for their operations.
Broader Crypto Exodus from Canada
Gemini exiting Canada is part of a broader trend of cryptocurrency exchanges folding their operations in the country. Earlier, Binance, OKX, and Bybit also announced their departures, attributing their decisions to the increasingly restrictive compliance framework. In particular, the CSA’s rules limit the use of stablecoins without prior approval and impose stringent requirements for investor protections. These restrictions, aimed at preventing a repeat of the major insolvencies seen in the crypto sector (such as those of Voyager Digital and FTX), have created a compliance burden that many international exchanges find hard to bear.
However, not all exchanges have decided to leave. Kraken and Coinbase, for example, have opted to continue operating in Canada, complying with the CSA’s framework by filing PRUs. Coinbase, in particular, has emphasized the importance of the Canadian market and is working to introduce new products. One example is a stablecoin tied to the Canadian dollar.
Challenges for Global Exchanges in Canada’s Regulatory Climate
The regulatory environment in Canada is indicative of the challenges facing cryptocurrency exchanges globally. While countries like the U.S. and the European Union are gradually refining their regulations to provide clearer frameworks, Canada’s approach has been notably more restrictive. The CSA’s measures are designed to mitigate risks for retail investors. Unfortunately, the complex compliance standards have deterred many exchanges from continuing their operations in the country.
Gemini’s departure underscores the difficulties that arise when regulatory environments differ significantly across regions. It also highlights a growing divide. Some jurisdictions are developing crypto-friendly policies, others are ramping up regulatory scrutiny. For crypto exchanges, navigating these varying regulations remains a significant challenge, and decisions like Gemini’s may signal a trend of exchanges prioritizing markets with more favorable regulatory conditions.
>>> Read more: Bank of Canada Halts Digital Loonie Over Privacy Concerns
As the regulatory landscape for digital assets continues to evolve, Gemini’s decision to exit Canada reflects the growing difficulties for cryptocurrency exchanges to operate in highly regulated markets. The exchange’s departure, alongside others like Binance and OKX, points to the broader challenges of complying with stringent oversight measures. For Canadian users, the exit of major exchanges represents a significant shift in the accessibility of crypto services. For the global crypto industry, it highlights the pressing need for harmonized regulatory approaches across jurisdictions.
Readers’ frequently asked questions
Why are other exchanges besides Gemini also leaving the Canadian market?
The exodus of multiple cryptocurrency exchanges from the Canadian market is largely due to the country’s evolving regulatory landscape, which has introduced more complex compliance requirements. The Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) implemented new rules that require exchanges to sign pre-registration undertakings (PRUs). They must abide by stricter investor protection measures. These include restrictions on trading certain assets like stablecoins, which have to be approved by the CSA, and enhanced guidelines for handling customer assets. For many exchanges, these requirements represent a significant operational burden that may not align with their global strategies. Binance, OKX, and Bybit, among others, have found these conditions untenable. They decided to withdraw rather than adjust their services to meet the new standards. The departures reflect a broader concern that Canada’s stringent regulatory framework may limit the flexibility and profitability of international crypto exchanges operating in the country.
What could this mean for the global crypto regulatory landscape?
Gemini’s exit from Canada is part of a broader trend of regulatory divergence across the global cryptocurrency landscape. While some jurisdictions, like Canada, are focusing on tightening rules and ensuring higher investor protections, others are working to create more business-friendly environments. This divide could result in an increasingly fragmented global market, where exchanges must adapt to different sets of rules depending on the country they operate in. For example, the European Union is working on comprehensive legislation under the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation, while the United States is still deliberating on how to regulate cryptocurrencies effectively. These disparities could lead to exchanges prioritizing markets with clearer or more favorable regulations. They may potentially bypass more restrictive regions like Canada. It also raises questions about the long-term viability of crypto platforms that must constantly adjust their operations to comply with a wide variety of global regulations.
What options do Canadian crypto users have after Gemini’s departure?
With Gemini leaving Canada, users in the country still have some alternatives, though the number of options is shrinking. Exchanges like Kraken and Coinbase continue to operate in the Canadian market. They have adjusted their platforms to comply with the Canadian Securities Administrators’ (CSA) new regulations. These exchanges have filed the required pre-registration undertakings (PRUs), allowing them to remain compliant with Canada’s regulatory framework. Additionally, Canadian users may explore local platforms such as Bitbuy or Newton, which have also adhered to the country’s regulatory standards. However, the overall shrinking number of available exchanges could result in fewer choices for users and potentially less access to a diverse range of cryptocurrency products.
What Is In It For You? Action Items You Might Want to Consider
Withdraw Your Assets Before the Deadline
If you’re a Gemini user in Canada, make sure to withdraw all your crypto assets and fiat funds before the December 31, 2024 deadline. Transfer your cryptocurrency to a secure external wallet or another exchange that continues to operate in Canada, like Kraken or Coinbase. Any funds left after this date may be inaccessible, so act now to avoid complications.
Evaluate Your Exchange Options
With Gemini leaving, it’s time to review alternative platforms that comply with Canadian regulations. Consider platforms like Kraken and Coinbase, which have adapted to the new compliance requirements, or explore local options such as Bitbuy or Newton. Look for exchanges that meet regulatory standards and provide the trading features and asset pairs you need.
Stay Informed on Regulatory Changes
Canada’s regulatory landscape for crypto is continuously evolving, and this may affect your trading strategies. Keep up with the latest updates from the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) and other regulatory bodies. Staying informed will help you anticipate any further changes and adjust your trading approach to maintain compliance and mitigate risks.
